Tools
Prediction published on May 15, 2026 2:03 PM by Dario in England - Premier League | Modified on May 15, 2026 2:03 PM
The Premier League season is nearing its conclusion, and Sunday’s clash between Everton and Sunderland promises to be a lively affair at the Hill Dickinson Stadium. With both sides sitting in mid-table and showing defensive vulnerabilities in recent weeks, this encounter could deliver plenty of goalmouth action. The Toffees, currently 10th, will be eager to end their home campaign on a high, while the Black Cats, placed 12th, are still mathematically in the race for a top-half finish.
Everton come into this fixture after a 2-2 draw away to Crystal Palace, a result that extended their winless streak to five league matches (three draws and two defeats). Despite their struggles, they have shown attacking intent, averaging 1.8 goals scored per game during this run, though their defense has been far from solid, conceding an average of 2.2 goals per match. Their inability to maintain leads has cost them valuable points in recent weeks.
At home, the Toffees have collected 23 points from 18 matches this season (six wins, five draws, seven defeats). Historically, they have enjoyed success against Sunderland, winning three consecutive home meetings before a setback in the FA Cup earlier this year. However, their defensive lapses have become a concern, with at least one goal conceded in each of their last five league outings.
Statistically, Everton’s matches tend to come alive after the break. There have been over 0.5 goals in the second half of each of their last 19 games, and both teams have scored in the second half of their last five Premier League fixtures. Conversely, the first halves have been more cautious, with under 1.5 goals at half time in their last 11 home matches. This pattern suggests that late drama could once again define their final home appearance of the season.
Sunderland arrive on Merseyside following a goalless draw against Manchester United, a result that extended their winless run to four league matches (two draws and two defeats). During this period, they have conceded 10 goals while finding the net only four times, underlining their inconsistency in both boxes. Their last victory came against Wolves, but since then, they have struggled to convert chances into wins.
On the road, the Black Cats have earned just 18 of their 48 points this season (four wins, six draws, eight defeats). Despite this modest return, there are signs of improvement: six of their 14 away goals have come in their last three trips, indicating a more adventurous approach in recent weeks. Their matches also tend to open up after halftime, with over 0.5 goals in the second half recorded in 26 of their last 29 Premier League games.
Defensively, Sunderland have often found themselves trailing early, having lost at half time in seven of their last 11 away matches. This could be a key factor against an Everton side that usually starts strongly at home. However, the visitors have shown resilience, managing to score in both previous meetings with the Toffees this season, including a 1-1 draw in January.
Both teams have endured mixed campaigns, and this fixture offers a chance to finish on a positive note. Everton’s attacking players have been in decent form, but their defensive structure has faltered, leading to high-scoring encounters. Sunderland, meanwhile, have been more unpredictable, alternating between solid defensive displays and open, end-to-end contests. Given the trends, this match could follow a similar pattern to their previous meetings, where both sides found the net.
Historically, Everton have dominated this fixture, boasting a record of three wins and two draws in their last five encounters, with an average of 2.0 goals scored and only 0.4 conceded per game. However, recent form suggests that Sunderland are capable of challenging that record, especially given their improved attacking output on the road. Both teams have drawn their last two league matches, and with neither side particularly strong defensively, another stalemate with goals seems plausible.
Considering the attacking trends and defensive fragilities on both sides, the data points toward another open contest. The most likely outcome according to the BetMines model is Both Teams To Score (Yes) with a probability of 51%. Everton’s recent home matches and Sunderland’s away form both support this scenario, making it a logical choice for bettors seeking value in the goals market.
This section provides average statistics and percentages on the main markets for the last 10 matches of both teams
Everton
Sunderland
Under
Over
Under
Over
0.5
0
10
1
9
1.5
0
10
5
5
2.5
2
8
6
4
3.5
5
5
7
3
4.5
8
2
8
2