Tools
Prediction published on Jan 9, 2026 6:03 PM by Dario in England - FA Cup | Modified on Jan 9, 2026 6:03 PM
The third round of the FA Cup brings one of the most anticipated clashes of the weekend as Manchester United host Brighton & Hove Albion at Old Trafford. The two sides last met in this competition in 2023, when United advanced after a dramatic penalty shootout. This time, both teams arrive with mixed form and plenty to prove, making this encounter a fascinating one for fans and bettors alike.
It has been a turbulent start to the year for Manchester United, who remain without a permanent manager and are winless since Boxing Day. Their most recent outing ended in a 2-2 draw against Burnley, marking their third consecutive league draw. Despite their struggles, the Red Devils have shown resilience at home, remaining unbeaten in their last four matches at Old Trafford, though three of those ended level.
In the FA Cup, United have an impressive record, losing only two of their last 40 third-round ties. They have also scored at least once in 24 of their last 25 matches in the competition, underlining their attacking consistency. The team’s recent switch back to a four-man defense has improved their offensive output, with 30 shots and 10 on target in their last match. However, defensive lapses remain a concern, as they have kept just one clean sheet since early October.
With key players returning from injury and others still away on international duty, United’s depth will be tested. Yet, their attacking options remain strong, and the home crowd will expect a response after recent disappointments.
Brighton & Hove Albion arrive in Manchester buoyed by a hard-fought 1-1 draw against Manchester City at the Etihad. The Seagulls have shown great character this season, collecting 13 points from losing positions in the league. However, their overall form has been inconsistent, with just one win in their last eight matches across all competitions.
On the road, Brighton have struggled recently, going four away games without a win (D2 L2) and conceding two or more goals in three of those. Nevertheless, they have a strong scoring record, with over 1.5 goals in 20 of their last 21 away fixtures. Historically, they have enjoyed success at Old Trafford, winning three consecutive matches there before losing 4-2 earlier this season.
Brighton’s attacking play remains their biggest strength, with several creative midfielders and forwards capable of unlocking defenses. However, their defensive vulnerabilities, especially away from home, could be exploited by United’s pace and movement in the final third.
This FA Cup tie promises to be an open and entertaining contest. Both sides have shown attacking intent in recent weeks, but neither has been particularly solid at the back. United’s home advantage and attacking depth could give them the edge, yet Brighton’s ability to recover from setbacks and their strong scoring record suggest they will not go down easily.
Historically, this fixture has produced goals, with the last meeting ending 4-2 in favor of United. Given both teams’ current form and defensive fragility, another high-scoring encounter seems likely. The Red Devils will look to capitalize on their home momentum, while the Seagulls will aim to continue their impressive FA Cup record of losing only two of their last sixteen third-round ties.
Based on the statistical trends and recent performances, the BetMines prediction for this FA Cup clash leans towards Both Teams To Score (Yes) with a 59% probability. Both sides have been prolific in front of goal but inconsistent defensively, making this market the most appealing option for bettors.
With United’s strong home scoring streak and Brighton’s attacking resilience, goals at both ends appear highly likely. Expect an exciting match filled with chances, intensity, and the trademark unpredictability of the FA Cup.
This section provides average statistics and percentages on the main markets for the last 10 matches of both teams
Manchester United
Brighton & Hove Albion
Under
Over
Under
Over
0.5
1
9
0
10
1.5
2
8
3
7
2.5
2
8
4
6
3.5
6
4
8
2
4.5
8
2
10
0